March 22, 2002
Dear Artist;
A situation that often disturbs artists is the competing prevalence of sub-standard art. To artists who have achieved a degree of professionalism but who have not as yet achieved a reputation, this can be discouraging. A frequent complaint is "bad" art from "good" names.
In a recent silent auction there was an oil by one of the local darlings--an elderly artist who has received a flood of attention over the last few years. The auction painting would have been rejected by any jury in any other city. It would even have been hazardous to put it in an art school application portfolio. And yet eager bidders hovered over the piece all evening and it eventually sold for a high price. Were they looking at the name rather than at the art? Was this yet another outbreak of the king's new clothes syndrome?
The artist in question has paid his dues. He has a lifetime of struggle behind him with ups and downs in creativity and success. He would receive top marks for persistence. His high periods were notably glorious. Who knows what people will think of his work in a hundred years. Who knows, indeed, where the fickle monkeys of taste may wander. In a way we tend to honor our artists by their totality--their life commitment to their profession. It's a kind of bonus that dedication brings to some artists in later years. For youthful artists to find injustice in the honoring of elderly artists is to do our profession a disservice. While we must always keep an eagle eye for what we think is quality, we ought also to honor all art, good and bad, fresh out of school, unschooled, or past its prime. It's the spirit that counts.
The artist donated his work. A friend of mine was the successful bidder. His money went to a noble charity. Wearing a broad grin my friend carried it away. He was taking home a piece of the action, an intimation of immortality, a slice of the famous spirit.
Best regards,
Robert
PS: "Though age and infirmity overtake me and I come not within sight of the castle of my dreams, teach me still to be thankful for life and for time's oldest memories that are good and sweet, and may the evening's twilight find me gentle still." (Max Ehrmann)
Esoterica: For those who wish it, art can be performed until the very end. There is no mandatory retirement in art. Georges Braque said: "With age, art and life become one." Let us honor life. Let us honor the life of an artist. "I am old and ill, and I have sworn to die painting." (Paul Cezanne)
The following are selected responses to the above and other letters. Thank you for
writing rgenn@saraphina.com
+Situational aesthetics
During the 60's we had situational ethics, during the 21st century we have situational
aesthetics. Bad art is not bad to the people whose aesthetic education is limited. They
use personal values such as subject, color, price and their experience to determine
whether a work of art is good or not. On the other hand, the aesthetic judgement of time,
peers and art gatekeepers is a high standard for us all to aspire to. Knowing the
difference is important and depends on your personal situation, values and goals.
Bob Ledoux, CONNART200@aol.com
+Bravo
There is no doubt that elderly artists deserve respect in their
successes and failures because, as you say, "they have paid their dues." Maybe
this scenario is more common than I think, but in my spectrum, what happens when it is
young artists throwing a bunch of crap together on a plate in 2 minutes and calling it
art? How much of an annoyance is it, when these young people, who probably happens to
either be a son or daughter of an art critique, museum curator, or university professor,
get rave reviews and gallery shows for lining up a row of old beer cans or tampons and
picking a trendy cause to back it up? What are the dedicated artists spending hours a day
in their studios mixing, sculpting, painting, weaving, etc...supposed to believe? That it
doesn't matter what you do, but who you know? So bravo to the elderly painter and their
bad painting, because at least he took the time to sit down and compose and feel enough to
pick up a brush.
Tahtiana tahtiana@magpage.com
+Past its prime
It is terrible to think that one day, I might not be able to produce a good painting. Reminds me of an elderly artist I met when I was still in art school. His name was Dimitri Romanofski and his studio was in the tower above Carnegie Hall overlooking Central Park. He was Russian and painted water lilies in a glowing impressionist style. He was very much past his prime, but he loved to dab away at work he'd finished years before, always hoping to make improvements. His closest friends had begun hiding the best of his work from him so he wouldn't destroy a masterful piece with his shaking hand and his fading sight.
But, Robert, are you sure you're not being too subjective, judging work to be 'good' or 'bad' simply based on your own bias? Obviously at least a few folks disagreed with your assessment at the auction. True, they may have been interested in acquiring a piece from a well-known artist without regard to the quality of that particular painting, but there's also the possibility that they saw something in the work that you didn't.
Eleanor Blair, Gainesville FL EBlairstar@aol.com
+Good art?
Please define poor quality art. And explain to me why Charles
Saatchie snaps up anything Daimien Hurst and the rest of the Britart bunch produces. Dead
butterflies embedded in gloss paint, this is good art?
Sally Webster, Scotland weegiftshop@thefreeinternet.co.uk
(RG note) Art thrives on a difference of opinion. My treasure is
your junk, sort of thing. Life would be dull if we all agreed. In life and art we need to
make sure that we honor that which our hearts and brains tell us is good. And we should
cast a philosophic yet curious smile at that which our hearts and brains tell us
otherwise.
+Why do they persist?
I often wonder about 'artists' who do really bad work, yet persist long past the point
where one would expect them to say, "Well, I guess I just can't do this art stuff.
I'd better get back to selling shoes, or whatever." Why do they insist on attempting
to make art? I don't know, except perhaps they simply need to express. If they were as
incapable at some other trade, like operating heavy equipment, they wouldn't be able to
get a job. I don't believe 'time on the job' has any place in judging the quality or value
in the work. Unfortunately, I don't have any answers to deal with the subjective quality
of art. It remains a mystery to me, so all I can do is try to do my best work and hope
that someone isn't saying about me, "Why does he persist?"
Ron Stacy stacystudios@shaw.ca
+Wondering what makes the difference
I really appreciate the point of view of honoring the whole life of the artist, but feel
more inspired by artists whose flame burnt brightest at the end. The comment that comes to
mind is that Cezanne, Degas, Monet and a number of other artists who painted to the end,
did some of their best work in their later years. Their mastery, along with the knowledge
that there wasn't much time left, led to originality and paring down. Totally new work,
rather than plagiarizing of oneself, resulted. I wonder what makes the difference, that
some artists end up basically doodling, following a habit that has been a satisfying one,
and others cannot help but innovate?
Jane Shoenfeld jane@skyfields.net
+The company you keep
What happens when a local "artist" (I'd rather use the word "painter")
submits work to a so-called juried show and is accepted because of his/her standing in the
community, not because the work is good? Or simply, is it because their feelings would be
hurt, if they weren't included? This makes it difficult for an accomplished artist: When
your work is shown with amateurs, where does that put you? You're known for the company
you keep, so does this downgrade your work and lose you clients, or does it upgrade their
work, and lose you clients because theirs is cheaper? Art in a small town is treated
differently than in a big city, for sure.
Jane Champagne, Southampton, Ontario janec@bmts.com
+Perennial students
I and my two good artist friends, all on our later years, both as artists and women still
think of ourselves as perennial students. We’re always ready to try different
techniques. Excited to win a juried competition award, always expecting that
"Blue", oh and the excitement that comes as you go to the studio first thing in
the morning after painting late the night before to see if the piece is still holding up.
How blessed we are to have art in our lives! Max Ehrmann’s comment reminded me of
something our late good friend said to me, "Liz, I just want to win that "Best
of Show" before I die."
Liz Maness, Wimberley, TX
. lamaness@wimberley-tx.com+Contest entries
"Mary’s chipmunks" oil, Beverly Theriault, Plano, TX BEVERLY.THERIAULT@PUBLICANS.COM
"River" oil, Elizabeth Schamehorn schamehornelizabeth@hotmail.com
"Twice ‘round" oil, Martine Gourbault gomargo@shaw.ca
"Swan Solitude" acrylic, Bonnie Hamlin bhamlin@mb.sympatico.ca
"Early cascade snow" W/C Bill McCusker, Ridgefield, WA wgmmm@attbi.com
(RG note) The above are a few more of the 350 or so entries that have come in since the contest was announced. They are not necessarily finalists in the "Free Painting Workshop in Brittany with Robert Genn" contest. You can get more information on this contest and workshop at http://www.painterskeys.com/workshops.htm The contest is open until June 15, 2002. All finalists will receive a free copy of The Painter’s Keys book. The workshop takes place from September 20 to 30th, 2002. Cost of the workshop is US$2350. The Robert Genn information for Phil Levine Workshops Inc. is at http://www.paintingfrance.com/Robert_Genn.htm
Please note that in the event that the winner of the contest has already signed up for
the Brittany Workshop, his or her deposits will be refunded and air transportation from
anywhere in the world will be looked after as well. Artists entering the contest who wish
to send regular photos of their work may send it to R Genn, 12711 Beckett Rd., Surrey, B
C. Canada, V4A 2W9. These will be scanned and transferred to our contest archive. Thanks.
þ
Please feel free to comment on anyone’s remarks. If you add your email address
right after your name at the end of your letter, we will include it. If you wish to write
incognito we will honor that too. All unused letters are carefully archived for possible
future use. We generally include ten or so letters in each "clickback" so you
can expect about the same amount of reading. Readers really appreciate it when you tell us
approximately where you are located. We edit most letters for clarity and brevity. We are
able to translate letters from most languages. Please address your letters to rgenn@saraphina.com
You may be interested to know that artists from every state in the USA, every province
in Canada, and at least 97 countries worldwide have visited these pages since January 1,
2002. That includes: Carol Lyons ArtfulCarol@aol.com
who says; "I do not honor bad art of any kind, whether done by a famous artist or a
child in kindergarten. I do not honor "bad" anything." Marina Morgan MCM@shk.bc.ca who asks "Why does this subject remain
such an emotional, ego-centered issue for visual artists?" Annette Waterbeek beek@intergate.ca who writes, "Doing the good art
along with the bad art...you can't have one with out the other." And Barbara Mason bemason@concentric.net who writes: "This
story does want to make you go through your studio and destroy stuff......but I have never
done so because it’s my personal history."
Three free books. Thanks so much for your enthusiastic endorsement of this letter. Apart from a few who find The Painter’s Keys on the internet, the only way artists hear about it is through the recommendation of friends. To make it more fun for you we have five copies of the Painter's Guide to Color, five copies of Design and Compositional Secrets of Professional Artists, and ten copies of The Painter's Keys. To win one of these books just send us the names of five friends or fellow artists who would like to get the Twice-Weekly Letter. We’ll close the lottery and make the draw on April 15, 2002 and announce the winners on April 16. Your free book will be in the mail to you on that day.
You can send your friends' names directly to me at rgenn@saraphina.com and I’ll make sure you’re entered. Don’t forget to include your mailing address so we can mail your free copy. The last time we did something like this there were about forty subscribers who responded with five or more friends so you stand a pretty good chance of winning one of the books. If you send fifteen new subscribers we’ll put your name in the hat three times. Thanks for joining in.
Please send the names of your new subscribers laid out something like this:
Mary Jones
maryjones224976@hotmail.com acrylic, Artville, AlaskaEvery letter is personalized so don’t forget that we need their first names as well as their last. It might be an idea if you dropped a note or made a phone call to your friends to say that you have recommended them for the letter. We don’t like to send anything to anyone who doesn’t want it. There’s enough spam around these days and we don’t believe in sending anything that’s not wanted. You can assure your friends that when they become subscribers their addresses will never be sold or used for any other unpleasant purpose. The letter will always be free and they may of course unsubscribe at any time.
The Painter’s Guide to Color, by Stephen Quiller is a definitive guide to understanding color. 144 pages packed with valuable information by the popular color wizard. Sells for $24.95US.
Design and Composition Secrets of Professional Artists. is a 128 page, large format book published by International Artist Magazine. It’s sold on Amazon for $19.99US. The artists whose work and methodology are included are Donna Baspaly, Robert Bateman, Alessandra Bitelli, Alan Bruce, Don Farrell, Peter Folkes, Britton Francis, Robert Genn, Kiff Holland, Tom Huntley, Brian Johnson, Neil Patterson, Myfanwy Pavelic, Nancy Slaght, Mike Svob, and Ann Zielinski. It has hundreds of color illustrations and lots of text explaining each artist’s approach to the vital subject of composition.
The Painter’s Keys is a seminar in a book—Just about, but not quite, everything you need to know about how to be an artist. Sells for $18.00US
The twice-weekly letters are in Russian at http://painterskeys.narod.ru/
The twice-weekly letters are in French at http://www.painterskeys.com/fr/