The Painter's Keys Community For Artists

Search the Painter's Keys:

Yes, please go ahead, forward this clickback to a friend: by email or

Related Clickbacks:

Howard Pyle Anders Zorn A visit with Turner

Further information on "Orphan Works"

Article on Orphan works: Whose Work Is It, Anyway? by Scott Carlson in the Chronicle of Higher Education.

Orphaned photographic works draw concern from artists, families, copyright officials, originally from the Chicago Tribune.

Eric Vincent of Charleston, S. C., President-Vincent Media Group, Inc., and GryphonPIX, Inc. is well connected to this effort.

Article; The End of Copyright by Ernest Adams

Our Arch-World updates and artist finder.

To write to the U.S. Congress:

A complete list of U.S. lawmakers and their fax numbers can be found at Illustrators Partnership of America

Norman Rockwell
February 28, 2006

Dear Artist,

One snowy November afternoon I happened to be in Stockbridge, Massachusetts, and I knocked on the studio door of Norman Rockwell. He took his time coming and when he did he was in his smock with a pipe in one hand and a brush in the other. I handed him a small gift I had brought with me--one of those pens with a brush at the end. At that time you could get them only in Japan--where I had just been. "I can use this," he
Richard Nixonoil painting<BR>by Norman Rockwell
Richard Nixon
oil painting
by Norman Rockwell
 click image to enlarge
said as he tried it out on a small desk by the door. I told him I was an admirer from Canada and he said he had a lot of friends in Canada. His easel held a mostly-finished portrait of Richard Nixon. As I was well and truly into his studio, he started stuffing 8" x 10" glossies into a drawer. When I asked some technical questions, he stopped stuffing. In that short visit I learned a lot about his process--stuff I was dying to ask that wasn't in the books.

We talked for some time and he didn't offer me a drink. We got around to Maxfield Parrish (the subject of my last letter) and I detected a bit of discomfort. He told me that he had learned a lot from Parrish and that in some ways his career had taken off from his. I loved the Rockwell "surfaces," and I told him so--and he became more at ease.

In some ways there are parallels between Parrish and Rockwell--the rectilinear design, the profiles, the joy of caricature. Where Parrish took the effects of light and atmosphere to an extreme, Rockwell concentrated on character. Not in all works, of course; in some, reality itself is enough. Rockwell grew into his job as a Saturday Evening Post cover illustrator. His work was amateur and laboured at first, but he soon developed confidence and a feeling for quality. Like a lot of us, he tightened up as he became older. To cruise his originals for the lovely brushwork is my idea of a great way to spend a day. Since that brief time with Rockwell, I've attended several of his retrospectives. The crowded rooms were full of smiles. When all is said and done, there's something to be said for smiles. His humanity, his archetypical faces--now so much interwoven with the fabric of America--will be around for a long time to come. That snowy afternoon in Stockbridge, I told him that--and then he told me he had to get back to work.

Best regards,


PS: "I unconsciously decided that, even if it wasn't an ideal world, it should be. So I painted only the ideal aspects of it--pictures in which there are no drunken slatterns or self-centered mothers. Only foxy grandpas who played baseball with the kids and boys who fished from logs and got up circuses in the backyard." (Norman Rockwell)

Esoterica: Rockwell's references for the Nixon painting were 8" x 10" black and white glossies. One of them was squared off. It appeared he had followed it pretty closely. There were traces of the grid on the painting. The drawing had been done with a Conte pencil--several shades were on the tabouret beside his easel. Rockwell would have believed in Sir William Orpen's dictum, "A painting well drawn is always well enough painted."

Norman Rockwell
Clickback contributors:
Life imitates art by Odette Nicholson
'Stories' not inconsequential by Heidi E. Hehn
'Rockwell not a real artist' by Kathleen Knight
Good heart medicine  by Redenta Soprano
Rockwell's vulnerabilities exposed by Curtis Wilson Cost
Knocking on doors by James Kelly
<i>Parrish Blue</i> by Jerry Snyder
The discomfort of reference by Len Sodenkamp
Brandywine tradition by Coulter Watt
Limited palette painters by Douglas H. Dartnell
'Feeling of failure' in artists by Mary Madsen
Art must deal with sterner stuff by Brett Busang
Artists need the rewards of life by Cherie Hanson
Of glue and rabbits by Jack Richardson

How quotable are you?
Our Resource of Art Quotations is the largest of its kind. Lately we've been looking at the writing of those who contribute to these twice-weekly clickbacks. To see if you've been included just type your name--or any name for that matter--into the box below. Press "search" and thank you for being so quotable.
Browse Authors Index
Browse Quotations Categories
Submit quotations

Art Directory

Our Free and Premium art listings will increase your website(s) popularity with search engines.

Artists' Responses to Norman Rockwell by Robert Genn
Be sure to check our Archives for related material.


Response to 'Norman Rockwell' by Odette Nicholson :: Life imitates art

by Odette Nicholson, Saskatoon, SK, Canada

contact Odette Nicholson share Odette's letter with a friend

The reason I don't like Norman Rockwell is that his pictures express old-fashioned attitudes, no 'self-centered mothers' more than makes my point. Though I do very well by my children, the artist part of me exists and yes, she is a bit self-centered! Unreasonable candified expectations generated by men like Mr. Rockwell and others through the history of art, beginning with the first depictions of the placid mother Madonna, do us all harm. Life does imitate art after all!

, Other letters by Odette, Related material on Life imitates art, Odette Nicholson Website,
top of page


Response to 'Norman Rockwell' by Heidi E. Hehn :: 'Stories' not inconsequential

by Heidi E. Hehn, Whitehorse, YT, Canada

contact Heidi E. Hehn share Heidi's letter with a friend

You have chosen two of my favourite artists of all time. Where I live people
Alaska Highway Winter by Heidi E. Hehn, acrylic painting, 16 x 20 inches
Alaska Highway Winter
acrylic painting, 16 x 20 inches
 click image to enlarge
dismissively label these two artists only "illustrators" as they do me. Their techniques far surpass many of the so-called artists I have known, both dead and alive. And their compositions have inspired me to paint what I want - stories. I am no wielder of a pen but the brandisher of a brush. In reality, is not all painting the painting of a story and is not all art an illustration - an illustration of the story inside the artist? But it seems to me that art is often defined by the art elite as something that the public dislikes. If the people like it--it is not art but illustration. Rockwell and Parrish and Pyle and all those who chose to express in terms of storytelling are all confined to the back bin as inconsequential.

(RG note) Thanks Heidi. In illustration, technique is the servant of story. All reference—models, costumes, furniture, props, photos, etc. are put to work toward that end. Rockwell had in his studio a large "morgue" where he kept pictures of things that might be needed. If he were alive today he would google stuff and press "images." He also employed a photographer to help him with his "set ups." Neighbors and friends were often dressed up and pressed into service.

, Other letters by Heidi, Heidi E. Hehn Website,
top of page


Response to 'Norman Rockwell' by Kathleen Knight :: 'Rockwell not a real artist'

by Kathleen Knight, Teasdale, UT, USA

contact Kathleen Knight share Kathleen's letter with a friend

I took an introductory studio art class as a freshman in college with high hopes of excelling and doing more art. It went fine until we were assigned to create a scrapbook of various types of art, taken from magazines, and I chose a Rockwell Post cover as the example of drawing. The professor told me Rockwell was not a real artist and gave me a C+ for the assignment. This was a major discouragement, not unrelated to my majoring in sociology, and I didn't take myself seriously in art until many decades later. So it was a great pleasure to read that Rockwell is now held in high regard in many art programs!

, Other letters by Kathleen, Related material on 'Rockwell not a real artist'
top of page


Response to 'Norman Rockwell' by Redenta Soprano :: Good heart medicine

by Redenta Soprano, Orlando, FL, USA

contact Redenta Soprano share Redenta's letter with a friend

There is something to be said for inspirational works of art. In contrast to what the avant garde genre of the recent past has espoused, I believe if an artist can create something truly beautiful, that addresses and uplifts the human spirit (not necessarily sweet and schmaltzy, though that perception is in the eye of the beholder), they can bring a little light into this world. There is quite a bit of bad news around, so to me, a bit of eye candy can be good heart medicine. Why not?

, Other letters by Redenta, Related material on Good heart medicine
top of page


Response to 'Norman Rockwell' by Curtis Wilson Cost :: Rockwell's vulnerabilities exposed

by Curtis Wilson Cost, Kula, HI, USA

contact Curtis Wilson Cost share Curtis' letter with a friend

Okay, normally I enjoy your writings. This one I found offensive. You invaded
Curtis Wilson Cost in his studio
Curtis Wilson Cost in his studio
 click image to enlarge
Rockwell's process, uninvited. You got in his door with a trinket and today you expose his vulnerabilities to a wide audience? (Stuffing 8" x 10" glossies into a drawer) How would you like someone to do that to you? You better call before coming to my studio, Robert. I won't be letting you in.

top of page


Response to 'Norman Rockwell' by James Kelly :: Knocking on doors

by James Kelly, Ireland

contact James Kelly share James' letter with a friend

I'm lucky to live here in Ireland quite near Arthur Maderson. It's one of my goals this
James Kelly, original painting
original painting
 click image to enlarge
summer to get to speak to him by just 'knocking on his studio door.' I was advised that this is the best approach as he would more than likely decline a more formal approach. I hope I'm as lucky as you were with Rockwell. I really love Maderson's work. I love your letters and I love reading the feedback from other artists. Your letter is 'my art community.'

, Related material on Knocking on doors
top of page


Response to 'Norman Rockwell' by Jerry Snyder :: Parrish Blue

by Jerry Snyder, Reading, Pennsylvania, USA

contact Jerry Snyder share Jerry's letter with a friend

I'm assuming you've seen the DVD Parrish Blue – 27 minutes in the home of Maxfield Parrish starring Norman Rockwell and Maxfield Parrish JR. Why doncha come down and see my studio sometime?

, Other letters by Jerry, Related material on Parrish Blue
top of page


Response to 'Norman Rockwell' by Len Sodenkamp :: The discomfort of reference

by Len Sodenkamp, Boise, ID, USA

contact Len Sodenkamp share Len's letter with a friend

I find it profoundly humbling to hear of your encounter with Rockwell. As I read
Redfish Lake by Len Sodenkamp, oil painting
Redfish Lake
oil painting
 click image to enlarge
your words I felt the connection with him. When he began stuffing photos out of eyeshot. How many times I have felt uncomfortable with a visitor in my studio looking over my photographic scrap and reference material. Especially other artists. This need to push aside the notion that we even need such things as photographic visuals to paint our works. How embarrassed we might be to need a picture of a rose to help us remember its soft velvet petals. The truth is, even the blind poet needs to feel the wind on his face to express it in so many words.

, Other letters by Len, Related material on The discomfort of reference, Len Sodenkamp Website,
top of page


Response to 'Norman Rockwell' by Coulter Watt :: Brandywine tradition

by Coulter Watt, Quakertown, PA, USA

contact Coulter Watt share Coulter's letter with a friend

It may be of interest to note that both Maxfield Parrish and Norman Rockwell
The chinese wedding vase by Coulter Watt, oil painting, 24 x 24 inches
The chinese wedding vase
oil painting, 24 x 24 inches
 click image to enlarge
studied with Howard Pyle in the Brandywine Valley of Pennsylvania, as did N.C. Wyeth, Harvey Dunn and Frank Schoonover and a few other very fine illustrators of the period. Howard Pyle is considered the father of American illustration. The Brandywine River Museum, in Chadds Ford, PA, is a worthwhile destination for anyone interested in these artists or this period.

, Other letters by Coulter, Related material on Brandywine tradition, Coulter Watt Website,
top of page


Response to 'Norman Rockwell' by Douglas H. Dartnell :: Limited palette painters

by Douglas H. Dartnell, Bow, NH, USA

contact Douglas H. Dartnell share Douglas' letter with a friend

I am enjoying your letters, especially about artists who used only a few colors, such as Anders Zorn and Maxfield Parrish. I had the opportunity to see first hand some of Zorn's portraits and his other paintings on my travels through Sweden and Finland last summer. I was blown away by Zorn's handling of color and its richness, especially in his portraits. I have always thought the Impressionists had the better method of presentation of various subjects with their bright colors and color variety, which were painted directly, either en plein air or in their studios. After seeing Zorn's works I could be easily swayed to another conclusion! I would be interested in hearing from other artists who use limited palettes.

, Related material on Limited palette painters
top of page


Response to 'Norman Rockwell' by Mary Madsen :: 'Feeling of failure' in artists

by Mary Madsen, Henderson, NV, USA

contact Mary Madsen share Mary's letter with a friend

One of the things I find most fascinating about Rockwell is that he, like so many
Mary Madsen, Mary Madsen
Mary Madsen
 click image to enlarge
outstanding artists in so many mediums, considered himself a failure. He left this world with a feeling of frustration and defeat because he wanted to be a fine art painter (whatever that means) and didn't realize what a wealth of images he created. Faulkner called himself a failed poet, and at Thoreau's funeral Emerson remarked that it was such a shame the poor boy had never lived up to his potential. I hope I leave this world frustrated and having failed to fulfill my potential in the same way these giants did.

, Other letters by Mary, Related material on 'Feeling of failure' in artists, Mary Madsen Website,
top of page


Response to 'Norman Rockwell' by Brett Busang :: Art must deal with sterner stuff

by Brett Busang, Washington DC, USA

contact Brett Busang share Brett's letter with a friend

I do appreciate your efforts to put a nice spin on things, but I'm afraid this last bit is just a "bit" too much. Siding with the likes of Norman Rockwell - who, by the way, did not necessarily "tighten up" as he got older - is to plant the American flag squarely in your Canadian pup-tent and start singing a nice, sentimental song about human brotherhood. You can obviously write anything you care to, but to see Rockwell as anything other than a talented fabulist is to be hopelessly caught in a sentimental swoon for something that never existed. Toward the end of his career, Rockwell began to realize the dark side of the myth he'd created and showed - if you'll remember - the shadows of his good old boys flung across a horrifying moonscape. In a moment, they would reach, and engulf, a black man cowering for support beside a white man who was similarly doomed. I notice that you always fail to print the "negative" things I say about the content of your sermons. Remember, however, what an excellent Romantic poet said about the artist's sense as a "negative capability." This means that however awful the source of an artist's inspiration, what explains or illuminates this source may ultimately transcend it. King Lear was a prideful old coot who ruined lives; Macbeth an ambitious murderer; Caesar's killers mere politicians who wanted Rome to themselves. Rockwell rarely thought about such things. The source of his livelihood was an America that was in denial about its racism, its labor policies, its ignorance of foreign militarism, and its brutal disregard for an environment that seemed to provide an endless abundance. The real story of America was told by its more fearless interpreters. (It's unlikely that you'll ever address them – though I would encourage it.) Rockwell's artistic significance is tantamount to that of a genial neighborhood storyteller whom everybody knows is embellishing shamelessly. They all listen to him anyway because they want to believe what he's saying.

I guess I may have to do my own newsletter. It's good to be likeable, but art has to deal with sterner stuff; people who have little else to do but grimace at one another don't cut it.

, Other letters by Brett
top of page
The Problem We All Live With, oil painting by Norman Rockwell, 1964
The Problem We All Live With
Oil on canvas by Norman Rockwell, 1964
(RG note) Somehow I just couldn't resist asking Andrew to put this one in here.


Response to 'Norman Rockwell' by Cherie Hanson :: Artists need the rewards of life

by Cherie Hanson, Kelowna, BC, Canada

contact Cherie Hanson share Cherie's letter with a friend

What appalls me is that creative people who are acting out their creativity feel
Tea house floats by Cherie Hanson, digital painting
Tea house floats
digital painting
 click image to enlarge
that they cannot find economic power and happiness. They pay for the privilege of being who they are with economic and relationship deprivation. We don't exact this price for success in other fields. It stems from the Protestant ethic, from the early history of North American culture. Artists need to get over it. Yes, we are exploring our soul's work. So are other people in other jobs. We need to claim the power of our vision and stop precluding ourselves from the rewards of this life. We are not, after all, medieval, expecting our reward in the afterlife and refusing to recognize or be recognized for the excellence of our work. It is a journey that starts one artist at a time. Allowing self to claim power, helping all others around us to see the beauty of their work, encouraging and networking are the ways that we can restructure the myth.

, Other letters by Cherie, Related material on Artists need the rewards of life, Cherie Hanson Website,
top of page


Response to 'Norman Rockwell' by Jack Richardson :: Of glue and rabbits

by Jack Richardson, Onancock, VA, USA

contact Jack Richardson share Jack's letter with a friend

My first year painting teacher, William Woodward, at Corcoran School of Art in
Jack Richardson, oil painting
oil painting
Washington DC, taught us students the use of "rabbit skin glue" for preparing canvas to isolate the support. For a number of years, about 40, I have used it in preparation of cotton and linen and also for paper. One benefit of use on paper, which is sized to start with, is that it leaves the color and texture much the same as before it is applied, (no glossy slick surface). I have papers which I sized (glued) 20 years ago and they still have the same wonderful tactual feel with no discoloration as before they were sized. I have also heard of, but never tried, a product called PVA, polyvinyl acetate, which is used for sizing and I would hope it has the same qualities as the rabbit skin glue. (Poor rabbits) Older methods still have their usefulness.

, Other letters by Jack, Related material on Of glue and rabbits, Jack Richardson Website,
top of page

World of Art Featured artist Janet Vanderhoof, Morgan Hill, CA, USA

Featured Artist Janet Vanderhoof, Morgan Hill, CA, USA
'The Way Things Used To Be</i> by Janet Vanderhoof, Morgan Hill, CA, USA
The Way Things Used To Be
Oil painting by artist  Janet Vanderhoof, Morgan Hill, CA, USA
Contact Janet Vanderhoof ::: More artwork by Janet Vanderhoof

You may be interested to know that artists from every state in the USA, every province in Canada, and at least 105 countries worldwide have visited these pages since January 1, 2006.

That includes David Kassan of Brooklyn, New York who wrote: "When in New York you should visit the Dahesh Museum of Art illustration show."

And also Leni Friedland of Mt. Sinai, New York who wrote: "In Stockbridge this past summer I bought an original copy of a Post magazine in mint condition with a Rockwell cover with my exact birthday date. It is now framed and hanging in my living room."

Simple gifts

Give some thought to giving the gift of the twice weekly letter. Andrew has set up a special place for this. You can send the letters to one special person or to as many friends as you wish. We will send these new people a card to inform them of your personal gift--and your good wishes. "The best things in life are free."

Please feel free to comment on anyone's remarks. If you wish to write incognito we will honor that too. Readers really appreciate it when you tell us approximately where you are located. It would also be great if you could include an image of your work or let us know where we might find some of your work on the net. We edit most letters for clarity and brevity. We are able to translate letters from most languages. Please address your letters to

All unused letters are carefully archived for possible future use. We generally include ten or so letters in each "clickback" so you can expect about the same amount of reading.

Previous ClickbackMaxfield Parrish click here to go to the top of this page Next Clickback:  Orphan works Orphan works

Robert's world-wide gift that artists love to get.

Absolutely free, no strings. Cancel at any time.
You'll get the valuable twice-weekly letter only.
Your email address will not be lent, sold or put
on any spam or other nasty list. Guaranteed.

Last modified: March 2, 2006 :: Copyright 2006 Robert Genn, All Rights Reserved